This transcript was ready by a transcription service. This model is probably not in its closing kind and could also be up to date.
Jeremy Owens: Hiya and welcome to On Watch by MarketWatch. I am Jeremy Owens. America had one other scorching month for jobs development in February, however many American employees aren’t feeling as highly effective because the numbers would recommend, and that is for good motive. We’ll dig into the numbers to indicate that it is just a handful of industries driving the expansion and element how you can navigate this uneven area. Then we check out the divide between women and men within the workforce. There’s lengthy been a niche between the pay that individuals obtain for a similar work, however the disparity runs deeper than that. Current information element that even in fields the place girls are the dominant majority of staff, they nonetheless path in pay. Plus, we’ll take a fast take a look at the information tales we’re watching proper now and the way they will have an effect on your pockets. First, let’s discuss in regards to the labor market.
After I discuss to the folks round me in regards to the labor market, the response just isn’t constructive whilst total jobs numbers proceed to indicate robust development. However I dwell within the shadow of Silicon Valley. So lots of the folks round me are within the know-how sector the place a wave of layoffs and price cuts has stalled job development. However not all my pals work in tech and even these in different industries inform me they don’t seem to be simply discovering new jobs and so they’re experiencing competitors and gradual processes once they do go after a brand new place. That appears to go in opposition to what can be anticipated within the tight labor market we have seen.
There are good causes although why the robust jobs market is not being felt extensively. MarketWatch reporter, Hannah Erin Lang, appeared deeper into the numbers and found only a handful of sectors have accounted for the overwhelming majority of latest job good points and the roles that are not rising as quick proper now or the place the ache is being felt. Lots of the layoffs occurring in America are aimed toward white collar employees who additionally aren’t experiencing the identical wage good points. Hannah joined us to speak by this divide and focus on what American employees can do to guard themselves.
Okay, Hannah, we received new jobs numbers final week and we proceed to see actually robust job development. Each month we get a whole lot of 1000’s of latest jobs, however that is not what folks appear to be experiencing on the bottom. And whenever you dug into these numbers, you probably did discover some fascinating issues that present that perhaps calling it an excellent job market is taking it slightly too far and actually uneven could be one of the simplest ways to say it.
Hannah Erin Lang: Yeah, I believe you are proper to say that by many measures, the job market seems to be actually good proper now, the headline numbers, unemployment has been under 4% for about two years, and the economic system added 3 million jobs in 2023. One other actually good quantity, however after I checked out these numbers slightly extra carefully, issues begin to get slightly bit extra difficult. Of the expansion that occurred in 2023, nearly all of the roles that have been added, about 75% have been concentrated in simply three industries, healthcare, authorities, and leisure and hospitality or inns and eating places primarily.
Jeremy Owens: Proper. And people three, you say mainly account for 3 out of each 4 jobs which have been created, which is excessive focus actually.
Hannah Erin Lang: Sure, sure, sure. So it is kind of extraordinarily lopsided, I believe could be an excellent phrase to explain it, and it’d clarify why loads of the employees I heard from when penning this story, significantly these in what we’d consider as extra conventional white collar workplace jobs instructed me, it does not actually really feel to them just like the job market is traditionally unbelievable, and that is as a result of in these sectors comparatively issues are slowing down.
Jeremy Owens: And people sectors you discuss, they rent loads of hourly wage staff and that appears to be the cut up after I discuss to folks anecdotally, is people who find themselves searching for extra of an hourly wage are discovering jobs open. However there’s loads of competitors inside these jobs and people who find themselves extra salaried and white collar workplace jobs will not be seeing loads of alternative to maneuver round and are literally slightly bit terrified of layoffs.
Hannah Erin Lang: Sure, sure. That matches with what I’ve heard anecdotally as effectively. And it additionally matches with what the information is telling us. And I believe that that is not essentially all dangerous information are these hourly employees, significantly after we take a look at some healthcare jobs or leisure and hospitality jobs, I imply, these are some decrease paid employees within the grand scheme of the economic system and so they’ve had some fairly spectacular wage good points over the course of the previous few years. I believe one other vital factor to notice right here is after we’re speaking about these white collar jobs, significantly in areas like tech that actually aggressively employed in these first few years throughout the financial restoration from the pandemic, it is nearly as if the labor market was operating so red-hot throughout that interval that even a reversion to what we could have as soon as considered “normalcy” goes to really feel like job market weak point or going to really feel like a slowdown when it might actually simply be a retreat from simply how scorching and aggressive the hiring was in that interval.
Jeremy Owens: Effectively, give me some recommendation for individuals who are on the market searching for a job with this job market being very particularly odd, uneven as we talked about. In your discussions with folks each searching for jobs and on the hiring facet, did you give you any ideas, hints for people who find themselves wanting proper now that they will use to attempt to get previous this?
Hannah Erin Lang: Yeah, so one factor that I reported on slightly bit up to now couple of weeks is this concept of how you can shield your self from a possible job loss or potential layoff, significantly on this atmosphere the place I do know that these anxieties are operating fairly excessive for folk, particularly once more in that company or white collar world. When you consider the large image, I imply that is nonetheless a very small a part of the economic system that is been impacted by job cuts although I do know that whenever you’re in these sneakers and nervous about that taking place at your organization, that could be slightly comfort.
I believe one factor that I’ve heard from profession coaches and employment attorneys is if you’re contemplating making use of for a brand new job and also you get provided a brand new job and also you’re nervous about switching jobs on this atmosphere, one vital factor that you are able to do is you may really negotiate or deliver to the bargaining desk a dialogue about your potential severance bundle in the event you have been to get laid off. So kind of the identical manner which you could negotiate your wage up entrance when taking a brand new job, whenever you’ve been provided the place. Profession coaches have been saying that that is one thing that is not essentially widespread however really has a fairly excessive charge of success, is attempting to barter a possible severance bundle up entrance, kind of the best way that you’d strategy a prenup. It is one thing that loads of of us go away on the desk, and it is one thing that you might do to present your self slightly bit extra peace of thoughts if you’re switching jobs and also you’re nervous about what that may imply on this atmosphere.
Jeremy Owens: Yeah. And in the event you do get known as in for a layoff, you may negotiate proper there on the spot. And I believe that is actually exhausting. I imply clearly getting laid off is likely one of the hardest issues, and it may be very exhausting to have the clear thoughts whenever you get known as in by HR for a layoff to suppose, “Now’s the time the place I really want to get essentially the most I presumably can out of the severance.” So what you are saying is there’s two methods to do this, get forward of it and know what your severance bundle could possibly be or be prepared in that second to attempt to negotiate greater to your severance bundle.
Hannah Erin Lang: I believe one thing like a layoff may be very troublesome, however the argument is that whenever you’re in that scenario, there’s perhaps not a lot that you’ve got left to lose. And what I’ve seen beneficial is attempting to level to ways in which this may occasionally profoundly have an effect on you, significantly perhaps you relocated for the job and perhaps you are on a work-based visa, pointing to these issues and pointing to how severely this may have an effect on you might provide you with slightly little bit of a greater likelihood of negotiating a extra favorable severance bundle. There is no assure, however there’s that argument there that in that second, when you have the braveness to advocate for your self, you do not have a lot to lose.
Jeremy Owens: And for individuals who is probably not nervous about getting laid off or these trying to get a brand new job, are there good methods to navigate this uneven market?
Hannah Erin Lang: I believe that that is an period by which private connections are king. As any individual who’s working in an business in media the place layoffs are fairly widespread, and I’ve heard anecdotally that individuals have discovered a solution to break by this kind of sluggish hiring, I believe that non-public connections and networking is kind of high of thoughts. And I’d additionally say that this can be a possibility to pursue a barely totally different path than maybe a company one if that was a previous profession that you simply had and also you’re now contemplating a transition.
One individual I spoke to for this story in regards to the jobs market received laid off from her job as a company tech recruiter and determined that this was a possibility to start out her personal enterprise and begin one thing fully new and embark on a unique journey that perhaps would not have these considerations of reductions in drive and all of these sorts of insurance policies hooked up to it. So I all the time really feel slightly conflicted providing Pollyanna sort recommendation like that about one thing like layoffs, which is one thing that may in fact be so disturbing. However I believe that it isn’t inconceivable, and it might be that the numbers and the headlines that you simply’re experiencing may paint a darker image than the precise actuality. And the fact is that the labor market is wholesome and there are nonetheless jobs on the market.
Jeremy Owens: Effectively, thanks a lot for approaching and serving to us give our listeners that nuanced image Hannah. Thanks a lot once more and we’ll have you ever again.
Hannah Erin Lang: Thanks a lot for having me.
Jeremy Owens: We will take a fast break. Arising, a take a look at the gender pay hole. Stick with us. Welcome again to On Watch by MarketWatch. Earlier than the break, we talked with MarketWatch reporter Hannah Erin Lang in regards to the job market.
Inside the scorching employment sectors we simply mentioned are jobs which can be dominated by girls corresponding to nursing and instructing. Whereas almost three and 4 folks employed in these professions are girls, they nonetheless obtain much less on common than males. And this was simply one of many details shared this Tuesday for Equal Payday, an annual occasion meant to focus folks’s consideration on the truth that women and men will not be compensated equally for a similar work. That is in keeping with a brand new report from the Institute for Ladies’s Coverage Analysis. MarketWatch senior reporter, Venessa Wong, took an curiosity in these findings and joins us now to debate why the pay hole is so persistent. So Venessa, yearly on Equal Payday, we obtain information on the place the pay hole stands proper now. Effectively, what did we discover out this yr?
Venessa Wong: Effectively, we have now discovered that the gender wage hole stands stubbornly round 84 cents on the greenback between women and men throughout the labor market in the USA. It is rather much like the wage hole that we have now noticed within the US for the final 30 years, kind of. Equal Payday is a reminder of how far we nonetheless need to go to until we attain pay fairness.
Jeremy Owens: And I’ve heard loads of makes an attempt to excuse this wage hole, and the one I hear essentially the most is, “Effectively, girls work in decrease paid jobs,” however the reality is even in professions the place girls are the dominant drive the place girls are nearly all of the employees, they nonetheless make lower than males in these jobs. May you give us some examples of what sort of jobs we’re speaking about right here?
Venessa Wong: So that is 100% true. In response to the brand new analysis from the Institute for Ladies’s Coverage Analysis, which is a suppose tank that is targeted on girls’s financial points, girls continued to earn lower than males within the 20 most typical occupations for ladies final yr. So this ranged from elementary and center college lecturers to nurses to secretaries, cashiers, instructing assistants, accounting, cleaners, retail employees. It did not matter what job you had in a male dominated occupation or a feminine dominated occupation, girls on common have been incomes lower than males in the identical jobs. And this was additionally true it doesn’t matter what race you have been. The most important gender wage hole was with Latina and black girls in comparison with white males, however the wage hole is pervasive throughout occupation and different demographic elements.
Jeremy Owens: I imply, simply to place some numbers behind it, you talked about elementary and center college lecturers. That is the commonest full-time occupation for ladies, and there is greater than a ten% earnings hole there that girls earn lower than 90 cents on the greenback for males in that occupation. Is there any motive behind this? I imply, is there one thing that individuals can level to and say that is the rationale for this wage hole in these particular professions?
Venessa Wong: That is such a tough query. I believe there’s been loads of legislative motion for many years at this level to attempt to handle the gender wage hole. However it’s very troublesome as a result of there isn’t a one single motive behind it that is simple to deal with with coverage. So we have now the Equal Pay Act, we have now Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. These are all from the Nineteen Sixties. Nevertheless, we’re very distant from that. And the wage hole persists, and I believe it is as a result of there’s loads of kind of undetectable bias, nevertheless it’s simply very troublesome. I believe it is also fascinating that a number of the professions that we talked about, corresponding to instructing and nursing are professions the place there’s loads of union exercise, proper? It is a strongly unionized workforce and the gender wage hole exists regardless of these efforts as effectively, proper? So Brookings for instance, did some analysis in regards to the wage hole with Okay-12 lecturers and located that there was some disparity as a result of male lecturers have been extra more likely to be paid for additional work.
And Brookings additionally discovered that when lecturers are compensated for that work, male lecturers are paid the next charge than feminine lecturers. So there’s loads occurring there. And curiously, Brookings additionally discovered that did not matter whether or not you have been within the unionized college district or not, they really discovered a barely bigger pay hole between female and male lecturers at school districts that had robust union participation.
So I believe unions are essential in kind of addressing the wage hole and have made very massive efforts to degree out pay throughout plenty of various factors, however there’s nonetheless loads of bias that makes its manner in. Plenty of this does need to do with girls taking over loads of caregiving tasks, and that impacts your earnings throughout your working life and in addition after you retire as a result of since your Social Safety advantages and your 401k, et cetera are all primarily based on what you earn throughout these years whenever you’re essentially the most energetic within the labor drive. However I believe what this analysis is simply saying is that no matter what your caregiving tasks are, there’s kind of a drawback for ladies within the workforce.
Jeremy Owens: A part of that drawback, even in girls dominated fields, usually the bosses is probably not all girls. Within the instructing instance you gave and that Brookings appeared into, whereas three and 4 lecturers have been girls, almost half the principals have been males, and there have been findings that male lecturers have been paid extra in colleges with male principals and we’re seeing particular lawsuits. I do know you talked about one in Houston, I consider, the place there are lawsuits in search of to shut this. There are efforts at this level particularly in instructing particularly to deal with this as a result of it does seem to be an space with excessive union exercise that you might attempt to handle this and slim it slightly bit.
Venessa Wong: That is proper. I imply, the EEOC is absolutely busy. There are nonetheless loads of lawsuits concerning wage discrimination in opposition to girls. 91% of Equal Pay Act prices between 2017 and 2021 have been filed by girls. So this continues to be an enormous difficulty for ladies in each section of the workforce, in each occupation, unionized or not, it doesn’t matter what race or ethnicity you’re. I simply needed to emphasise the universality of this downside. I believe there are loads of skeptics on the market who’re like, “Effectively, it is as a result of girls are in low-paying jobs,” which is 100% true, and that does account for a big share of what the wage hole is. However it’s similar to it does not matter in the event you’re part-time, you are full-time. It does not matter what job you might have, does not matter if the job you might have is a female-dominated occupation or not, there’s, I believe we are able to name it common discrimination.
Jeremy Owens: You talked about the EEOC. That is the Equal Employment Alternative Fee. It is a authorities company put answerable for searching for gaps like these for issues like this that they will attempt to remedy. And we have now seen some motion from Congress from DC to attempt to empower the EEOC extra and alter the legal guidelines, replace these legal guidelines you introduced up that have been put by within the sixties and seventies to attempt to make them stronger.
Venessa Wong: There’s loads of political motion occurring on the state degree, however I believe loads of advocates would say which you could’t kind of handle this on a state-by-state degree as a result of the issue is so common. So there is a piece of laws known as the Paycheck Equity Act that is made its manner by Congress a number of occasions and hasn’t managed to be handed attempting to shut loopholes within the Equal Pay Act. It might permit the EEOC to difficulty guidelines to gather wage data. It might make it unlawful for employers to ban staff from sharing their wage data, and it might make it unlawful to depend on a employee’s wage historical past in making compensation choices, which once more would perpetuate the present wage hole.
There’s additionally one thing known as the Wage Transparency Act, which might require employers to reveal both the wage or the wage vary in a job posting. So loads of the brand new laws is focused at wage transparency in order that there is no kind of secret preferential therapy, and I believe it may possibly assist, however I additionally consider that there is been wage transparency by collective bargaining that as we have now seen, has had incomplete outcomes. It isn’t that it isn’t working, it is simply kind of like not the silver bullet.
Jeremy Owens: Okay, Venessa. Effectively, I admire you coming by and speaking about this, and we’ll proceed to cowl the wage hole. Thanks a lot for becoming a member of us, and we’ll discuss to you once more.
Venessa Wong: Thanks a lot for having me.
Jeremy Owens: Earlier than we go, it is time for What We’re Watching, a take a look at the information you want to know for the remainder of the week and past. The newest inflation studying confirmed that costs are nonetheless growing at an elevated charge. The Client Value Index confirmed the most important bounce month over month in September of final yr. That was a 0.4% rise for February. The market was largely anticipating that scorching inflation studying, so markets didn’t take a success on the information, however expectations for rate of interest cuts from the Federal Reserve did undergo, with economists now doubting that transfer will are available Could. Reddit named its value declaring that it will be searching for $31 to $34 a share and an preliminary public providing anticipated subsequent week. That value would worth the social media firm at roughly $5 billion or extra, whilst the web site continues to lose cash in its twentieth yr of existence. IPOs have been scarce because the pandemic growth and choices died down. So Reddit is taken into account an vital check case for the market.
We’ll have extra on this story subsequent week. Subsequent week additionally brings loads of information on the housing market, together with the Residence Builder Confidence Index, housing begins, constructing permits, and present residence gross sales for February. The outcomes could possibly be grim because the housing market has been in a deep freeze amid rising mortgage charges. However will the arrival of Spring handle to thaw the housing market? We’ll discuss extra about that subsequent Thursday.
And that is it for this episode. Due to Hannah Erin Lang and Venessa Wong. To maintain following the most recent on the labor market and equal pay, head to marketwatch.com. You possibly can subscribe to the present wherever you get your podcasts, and please do. When you like what you heard, please go away us a ranking or overview. It actually helps others uncover the present and tell us what you need to hear from us. You possibly can attain us at onwatch@marketwatch.com, and in the event you’re a listener on Spotify, make sure to reply this week’s ballot. The present is hosted by me, Jeremy Owens, and produced by Mette Lützhøft, Katie Ferguson and Jackson Cantrell. Isak Gaines combined this episode. Melissa Haggerty is the chief producer. We’ll be again subsequent week with a brand new episode, and till then we’ll be watching.